State Aid Law Blog

State Aid Uncovered Blog

In Lexxion’s State Aid Uncovered blog, Prof. Phedon Nicolaides publishes weekly critical analyses of recent State aid judgments and decisions. Each post presents the key points of a court judgment or EU Commission decision, places it in the context of similar case law or practice, assesses the underlying reasoning and highlights any inconsistencies or contradictions.

Guest contributions from other State aid experts will also be published on the blog at irregular intervals to complement the content of the blog posts.

Subscribe now!

30. November 2017  |   State Aid Uncovered by Phedon Nicolaides

The Legal Basis of the (In)compatibility of Aid Must be Clear
State Aid Blogs - m 3 2
The European Commission may withdraw a decision, but before it adopts a new decision it must give an opportunity to interested parties to submit their comments, especially, if it changes the legal basis of the assessment of the compatibility of the aid.   Introduction The most frequent reasons for which the Commission finds aid to be incompatible with the internal […]
read more
No Comments
21. November 2017  |   State Aid Uncovered by Phedon Nicolaides

i) Transfer of State Resources, ii) Non-recovery of Incompatible Aid, iii) Primacy of Agricultural Policy over Competition Policy
State Aid Blogs - 21.11.State resources State control
Private resources that come under the control of a public authority become state resources. The only defence for not recovering incompatible aid is absolute impossibility. Agricultural policy objectives take precedence over those of competition policy. Introduction This article reviews a case involving transfer of state resources and a case concerning failure to recovery of incompatible State aid. It also draws […]
read more
No Comments
14. November 2017  |   State Aid Uncovered by Phedon Nicolaides

Existing v New Aid
State Aid Blogs - m 4 1
Any alteration of an existing aid measure can affect the substance of the measure itself. A deviation from the conditions of authorisation may turn existing aid into new aid. Alteration or deviation from the conditions of authorisation that affect the compatibility of an existing aid measure, can result in the granting of new aid. A Member State that alters an […]
read more
No Comments
7. November 2017  |   State Aid Uncovered by Phedon Nicolaides

Indirect v Secondary Effects of State Aid
State Aid Blogs - 07.11.sardinia airport State aid
The prohibition of State aid in Article 107(1) of the Treaty applies both to the direct and indirect beneficiaries of aid. The direct and indirect beneficiaries are those who are intentionally targeted by the aid. Secondary effects are benefits which are inherent in an aid measure and which are not targeted at specific undertakings.   Introduction Public funding for the […]
read more
No Comments
1. November 2017  |   State Aid Uncovered by Phedon Nicolaides

Activities Linked to State Prerogatives
State Aid Blogs - 01.11.17 State aid
Economic activities which cannot be separated from the exercise of public powers cease to be economic in nature.   Introduction The dividing line between economic and non-economic activities is in a permanent state of flux. Although it is now clear that some activities fall within the powers and prerogatives of the state, while many others are carried out by the […]
read more
No Comments
24. October 2017  |   State Aid Uncovered by Phedon Nicolaides

Private Creditor Test
State Aid Blogs - SAH Blog26 GBERd
The Commission must apply the private creditor test even if a Member State does not request it or believes that it is not relevant.   Introduction Private investors always have two options: to invest or not to invest. They choose the option that generates the largest amount of profit or revenue. Similarly, private creditors also have two options: call in […]
read more
No Comments
17. October 2017  |   State Aid Uncovered by Phedon Nicolaides

State Resources and Imputability
State Aid Blogs - 17.10. imputability stateaid
When the state acts in its capacity as legislator it is not presumed to direct the resources of undertakings it owns and over which it can exercise dominant influence as a shareholder. Introduction On 13 September 2017, the Court of Justice replied to a request from a national court to advise it on the concept of state resources [case C‑329/15, […]
read more
2 Comments
10. October 2017  |   State Aid Uncovered by Phedon Nicolaides

Pitfalls in the Use of De Minimis Aid
State Aid Blogs - 05.12.Imputability of Aid State aidz
Calculating de minimis aid according to the average amount of aid received by undertakings is wrong. Introduction It appears that all Member States grant de minimis aid, even though some tend to grant it more easily than others. De minimis aid can be used to subsidise any costs, including those which are not eligible under other State aid rules. The […]
read more
3 Comments
4. October 2017  |   State Aid Uncovered by Phedon Nicolaides

The Necessity and Proportionality of Regional Aid
State Aid Blogs - m 5 1
The Commission must open the formal investigation procedure when it has serious doubts about the compatibility of State aid. The aid that is necessary to induce a company to locate its investment in an assisted region is the amount that covers the difference in costs between the assisted region and the best alternative location. This amount is also proportional.   […]
read more
No Comments
26. September 2017  |   State Aid Uncovered by Phedon Nicolaides

Odysseus and the Sirens: A Rational Market Operator Can Agree to be Bound by the Ruling of an Arbitration Tribunal
State Aid Blogs - m 6 1
A rational market operator can agree to arbitration if there is no reasonable prospect of a better outcome. However, a rational operator would ensure that the terms according to which an arbitration decision can be taken would be defined in advance and would not be prejudicial to the operator.   Introduction Is it rational for a market operator to agree […]
read more
No Comments
« Previous PageNext Page »

8. November 2016  |   State Aid Uncovered by Phedon Nicolaides

1) Selectivity of Health Tests 2) Existing v New Aid in Preferential Electricity Tariffs
State Aid Blogs - m 14
A measure can be selective even if it applies to a whole sector. An existing aid measure becomes new when a court extends it temporarily.   Introduction This article reviews two judgments: one on BSE tests in Belgium and another on preferential electricity tariffs in Greece. The issue at hand with respect to the BSE test was whether a measure […]
read more
No Comments
1. November 2016  |   State Aid Uncovered by Phedon Nicolaides

Turnover Taxes Can be Incompatible with the Internal Market
State Aid Blogs - m 12 1
Progressive taxes levied on turnover can provide State aid that is incompatible with the internal market. Flat turnover taxes are proportional and therefore likely to be free of State aid.   Introduction Hungary wanted to levy two types of turnover taxes whose purpose was to protect health. The first tax was levied on tobacco products.[1] The Commission found, in decision 2016/1846, […]
read more
No Comments
25. October 2016  |   State Aid Uncovered by Phedon Nicolaides

Belgium’s Alternative Tax Regime for the Diamond Sector
State Aid Blogs - m 13 1
Alternative tax regimes do not provide State aid as long as they raise the amount of tax paid and they are justified by the nature or general scheme of the normal system of taxation.   Introduction During the past three years, the Commission has been pursuing multinational companies that pay too little tax. Its main objection to the tax treatment […]
read more
No Comments
18. October 2016  |   State Aid Uncovered by Phedon Nicolaides

Compliance with State Aid Rules in Cohesion Policy: A Special Report of the European Court of Auditors
State Aid Blogs - m 14 1
Control of State aid by national authorities needs to be strengthened. Typical mistake is to grant aid after a project has started or to subsidise ineligible costs. Aid measures for risk capital, SGEI and R&D appear to be particularly prone to error.    Introduction   On 4 October 2016, the European Court of Auditors [ECA] published a special report 24/2016 […]
read more
No Comments
11. October 2016  |   State Aid Uncovered by Phedon Nicolaides

Non-economic Activities, Absolute Impossibility to Recover Incompatible Aid and the Powers of National Courts
State Aid Blogs - SAH blog48 Montessori Lexxion
This article reviews three judgments that were all rendered on 15 September 2016. The first two concern the concept of economic activity. The third is about the rights of national courts to consider the correctness of Commission decisions. The Court of Justice has said clearly that national courts may not question Commission decisions.   Economic activity The first two cases […]
read more
No Comments
6. October 2016  |   State Aid Uncovered by Phedon Nicolaides

Compensation for the Extra Costs Imposed by Law
State Aid Blogs - m 15 1
When the state imposes obligations which create extra costs for a single undertaking, that undertaking suffers a disadvantage in relation to its competitors. The extra costs are abnormal because normal costs are those borne by all competitors. Introduction On 14 July 2016, the General Court rendered its judgment in case T 143/12, Germany v Commission.1 The outcome was a victory for […]
read more
2 Comments
27. September 2016  |   State Aid Uncovered by Phedon Nicolaides

Regional Aid for a Large Project subject to Individual Notification under the GBER
State Aid Blogs - m 16 1
In the meaning of regional aid rules, diversification in a “new activity” is not the same as diversification in a “new product”. A “new process innovation” must be different, in the sense of being distinct from an existing process, must be substantial, in the sense that it covers the whole production process and must be new, in the sense that […]
read more
No Comments
20. September 2016  |   State Aid Uncovered by Phedon Nicolaides

Non-State Aid Assistance to Depositors and Customers of Banks
State Aid Blogs - m 17 1
Public assistance to borrowers who cannot repay their loans does not constitute State aid if the beneficiaries are individuals. Public assistance to undertakings which cannot repay their loans does not constitute State aid if the amount of aid does not exceed the de minimis threshold. Any public funding of deposits which are transferred from ailing to healthy banks is not […]
read more
No Comments
13. September 2016  |   State Aid Uncovered by Phedon Nicolaides

Burden-Sharing and State Aid to Banks
State Aid Blogs - m 18 1
Creditors must contribute to the recovery of banks before State aid is granted. Burden-sharing by creditors in the recovery of banks does not deprive them of their right to property.   Introduction On 19 July 2016, the Court of Justice rendered its judgment in case C‑526/14, Tadej Kotnik and others v Državni zbor Republike Slovenije.[1] The judgment was in response to a […]
read more
No Comments
6. September 2016  |   State Aid Uncovered by Phedon Nicolaides

Commission Notice on the Notion of State Aid: Part III – Trade Effect, Distortion of Competition and Infrastructure
State Aid Blogs - m 19 1
This is the third and last article in a series of three that reviews the Commission’s Notice on the Notion of State Aid.* Last week’s article analysed the concepts of advantage and selectivity. This week the focus is on the last two constituent elements of the notion of State aid: affectation of cross-border trade and distortion of competition. This article […]
read more
No Comments
« Previous PageNext Page »

Subscribe to our newsletter for updates on legal developments, upcoming conferences, workshops, and publications in your areas of interest.

Newsletter: Subscribe now